• The Coffeehouse is Closed

    It is with a heavy heart we must inform you that the Intrigue Chocolate Coffeehouse, due to challenges presented by Covid-19, is now permanently closed. The official statement is released and negotiations with the landlord have concluded. Soon we’ll be moving out! Thank you to the whole Capitol Hill community for just over 3 incredible years, from dream to completion.

    That said, let’s celebrate the incredible journey that was building and growing a dream come true! The massive undertaking changed the chocolate we produce, how we do business, and it changed us. What an honor and privilege it was to have the opportunity to make so many incredible memories, to lead such a great team who cared deeply about your café-and-chocolate experience, to work with dedicated and passionate vendors like Conduit Coffee and Little Kitchen, and to meet so many of you wonderful people.


    The Coffeehouse Changed Our Chocolate

    We opened the Coffeehouse to show what was possible with coffee and chocolate. The two are natural partners – from mochas and hot cocoas, to sipping chocolates, to chocolate pastries and banana bread with cacao nibs, to cacao and coffee combo cold brews and slushies, to truffles and craft chocolate to enjoy with your coffee – the two just enjoy playing together. Specifically, we wanted to demonstrate how much better a chocolate drink tastes when using actual cocoa powder and chocolate, rather than the usual high-sugar low-cacao syrup from a pump bottle.

    We discovered that the average consumer thinks of chocolate as an occasional treat, coffee as a daily routine, and the combination of chocolate with coffee as something for people serious about neither ingredient. So, we quickly went to work on bridging the gap with the products we offered.

    This led us to pursue becoming makers of craft chocolate.

    Before this change, Intrigue Chocolate was considered a “confection” company. This means we made a confection with chocolate made by someone else. We used a base chocolate from Belgium for our truffle collections, and from that starting point developed over 400 flavors! They were all hand wrapped, hand stickered, and grouped into collection boxes that were hand folded and perishable.

    This level of chocolate experience was not often what customers were looking for at a coffeehouse, however. The truffles, in a sense, were great as giftable items, but too precious to be paired with coffee in the minds of our customers. So, we set to work making our own chocolate from the bean that was less expensive, non-perishable, and did not require as much explanation.

    We purchased a chocolate mill, as well as cracking and winnowing machines, learned to work directly with cacao beans, and set to work making smaller packets of chocolate with fruit inclusions, infusions, and multiple origins. Customers loved the colorful fruit, the flavors of the origin chocolate, and the lower price point. We came to think of it as “snacking chocolate”.

    We are grateful to the coffeehouse for forcing us to adapt and learn, and ultimately serve our all our chocolate-loving customers better.

     The Coffeehouse Changed Our Business

    The infant version of Intrigue began in February, 2005, but we really got rolling in late 2006, working in a shared commercial kitchen and selling our confections at wineries on the weekends. In 2009 we signed the lease on a space we converted into a kitchen in Pioneer Square, during years the neighborhood was struggling. In 2015, we opened a ground-floor retail shop in Pioneer Square - just three blocks from the kitchen - to accommodate increasing foot traffic attracted to us via our glowing online reviews. We also expanded the kitchen to a space next door that acted as our warehouse and office. Then we started building our coffeehouse in 2017 and opened in 2018.

    2020 has been a completely different kind of year. But, in so many ways the Coffeehouse was vital to our ability to navigate through all these challenges, one at a time. Even before COVID, we got the news that the building hosting our kitchen/office/warehouse would be gutted and converted to waterfront offices. We are grateful for the flexibility the coffeehouse provided as we pivoted in January. But now, as the challenge of COVID persists, we must close the Coffeehouse, too. Intrigue had grown to 14 team members in addition to owners Karl and Aaron. Intrigue is now just Aaron and Karl again, with a website, one retail location in Pioneer Square, and a cookbook full of chocolate recipes.

     The Coffeehouse Changed Us

    My Dad likes to ride motorcycles. At some point on the journey of his hobby, he twice decided to compete in the Iron Butt Rally, a long-distance riding competition. Competitors ride tens of thousands of miles over the course of two weeks, trying to maximize distance at the expense of sleep. Although he did quite well in both events (and took a strict stance on safety), he had a difficult time sharing the experience with friends and family. The first question everyone asked him was, “why would you bother doing such a thing in the first place?!” Aaron and I find ourselves facing the same question now about opening a café and being small business owners.

    The answer my Dad gave then was, “Because I wanted a challenge, and to learn about myself.”

    Although my Dad’s competition caused him a great deal of physical discomfort, he was beaming with pride at the end of both runs. He told us stories of riding through heavy rains as he tried to avoid hurricane Katrina which was south of him as he crossed the mid-states and north of him as he crossed back west through Canada. He met strangers who recognized the rider markers on his bike and the race he was competing in, and honked horns or cheered him on at gas stations. He told us stories of sleeping next to his bike on the side of the road. He told us stories of natural beauty he saw along the way.

    In a similar fashion, what we experienced in the 3 years of dreaming, building, and operating the coffeehouse makes for a lifetime of stories. Although there are too many to tell here, we would like to thank the community for the following:

    •  Open mic nights
    • Game nights
    • Conduit Coffee cuppings
    • Awkward first date
    • Awkward last dates
    • Awkward interviews
    • Students studying long hours (shout out to all those now calling themselves RNs!)
    • After-yoga socials
    • Parent / teacher meetups
    • Pumpkin carving
    • Coffee clubs
    • Chocolate Society gatherings
    • Classes with Atlas Obscura
    • Big Brother / Big Sister tutoring sessions
    • And a special thank you to everyone who visited us on the daily. You brought your kind smiles and positivity to the shop every day. You encouraged us and our staff. Know that together your small efforts made this coffeehouse what it was, and you are the stars of the stories we’ll tell for the rest of our lives.

    Thank you Capitol Hill for the opportunity to serve your community!

    - Aaron & Karl, Intrigue Chocolate Co.

  • Comments on this post (6 comments)

    • Kim says…

      I so admire your courage and creativity to persist and pivot [yet again]. I can’t wait to taste your new creations. Envisioning “Aaron Untethered” to imagine a whole new world of flavors – can’t wait to taste all you come up with!! Appreciate you both so much.

      on August 28, 2020

    • Barbie says…

      Tears in my eyes and lump in my throat at this news. So many wonderful memories. I’m glad you are still in Pioneer Square and look forward to your next snacking chocolate creation and your warm smiles.

      on August 25, 2020

    • Andi Noelle says…

      I am crushed. Intrigue Coffeehouse was our first, last and everyday stop every time we visited Seattle. We moved to Oregon and drove the 3.5 hours just to have your coffee. We will be visiting your Pioneer Square location to support your business and the fine art of chocolate that you enrich all our lives with.

      on August 24, 2020

    • John says…

      A grand experience shared by so very many by two very grand guys.Have the courage to continue your special journeys!

      on August 24, 2020

    • Keri Hicks says…

      damn. Sorry guys. Coffee, chocolate and wine is how I’m getting through this apocalypse.

      on August 24, 2020

    • Susan Afker says…

      Heartbroken to read this message. I would come after yoga many days each week and stay for a long while drinking your delicious special cofffee, made just by you. I am wondering whether you have any of your coffee left for sale. It woyluld be a wonderful way to tememer you all.

      Susan
      pSv I would often leave my yoga mat behind because I was so relaxed and your thoughtful staff would put it in a safe place for me

      on August 24, 2020

  • Leave a comment

Added to cart

c